---
title: "not getting into a philosophical debate, but this book really changed how I see the topic and made m..."
canonical: "https://new.nat6.net/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/"
date: "2025-12-22"
updated: "2026-11-05"
source: "X：谢赛宁 (@sainingxie)"
source_url: "https://x.com/sainingxie/status/2003193193656135855"
language: "zh"
topics: []
license: "https://new.nat6.net/sources/"
attribution: "Content is based on curated titles and AI summaries from the AIHOT public API, with attribution and links back; original copyright remains with the original publishers and authors."
---

# not getting into a philosophical debate, but this book really changed how I see the topic and made m...

- 发布日期 / Published: 2025-12-22
- 更新时间 / Updated: 2026-11-05
- 分类 / Category: 其他
- 来源 / Source: X：谢赛宁 (@sainingxie) — [原文 / Original](https://x.com/sainingxie/status/2003193193656135855)
- AIHOT: [条目页 / Item](https://aihot.news/items/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5)
- 页面 / Page: https://new.nat6.net/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/
- 结构化数据 / JSON: https://new.nat6.net/api/v1/articles/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5.json

- 语言 / Languages: [zh](https://new.nat6.net/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/) · [en](https://new.nat6.net/en/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/) · [de](https://new.nat6.net/de/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/) · [fr](https://new.nat6.net/fr/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/) · [ru](https://new.nat6.net/ru/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/) · [ja](https://new.nat6.net/ja/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/) · [es](https://new.nat6.net/es/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/) · [ko](https://new.nat6.net/ko/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/) · [vi](https://new.nat6.net/vi/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/) · [th](https://new.nat6.net/th/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/) · [id](https://new.nat6.net/id/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/) · [ms](https://new.nat6.net/ms/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/) · [fil](https://new.nat6.net/fil/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/) · [hi](https://new.nat6.net/hi/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/)

## AI 摘要 / AI summary

不想陷入哲学辩论，但这本书确实改变了我对这个话题的看法，让我更加谦逊。人类智能令人印象深刻，但称其为"通用"并不太客观。我的猫会不同意。 在我看来，人类智能更应被视为社会驱动的认知适应，而且我们仍不理解、也远未用当前 AI 复现的智能领域还有巨大 WORLD。 [引用 @demishassabis]：Yann 在这里完全错了，他把通用智能和 universal intelligence 混淆了。 大脑是我们在宇宙中所知最精致、最复杂的现象（迄今为止），而且它们实际上极其通用。 显然，没有人能规避 no free lunch theorem，因此在实际且有限的系统中，总是必须围绕正在学习的目标分布有一定程度的专门化。 但关于通用性的要点在于，理论上，在 Turing Machine 的意义上，这种通用系统的架构能够在给定足够时间和内存（以及数据）的情况下学习任何可计算的东西，而人脑（和 AI foundation models）是近似 Turing Machines。 最后，关于 Yann 对国际象棋棋手的评论，人类竟然能发明国际象棋（以及现代文明的所有其他方面，从科学到 747s！），更不用说像 Magnus 这样的人能下得如此出色，这本身就令人惊叹。他可能不是严格最优的（毕竟他有有限的记忆和有限的决策时间），但考虑到我们的大脑是为狩猎采集而进化的，他以及我们能用大脑做到这些，实在令人难以置信。

## 推荐理由 / Why it matters

顶级科学家对AGI本质的深刻思辨，重新定义通用智能的边界与局限

## 来源与版权 / Source & copyright

内容基于 AIHOT 公开 API 的精选标题与 AI 摘要，已注明来源并回链；原文版权归原媒体与作者所有。

原文版权归原媒体与作者所有；本站不镜像全文。/ Original copyright remains with the original publishers and authors; this site does not mirror full texts.

## 关于橙子中转站 / About Orange Relay

橙子中转站（pro.nat6.net）是一家优质的 AI API 中转站：价格优惠、质量稳定、模型齐全，支持 Claude、GPT、Gemini 等主流模型，欢迎体验。

[访问橙子中转站](https://pro.nat6.net/?utm_source=orange_news&utm_medium=article_footer&utm_campaign=brand&lang=zh)

## JSON-LD

```json
{
  "@context": "https://schema.org",
  "@type": "NewsArticle",
  "@id": "https://new.nat6.net/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/#article",
  "mainEntityOfPage": {
    "@type": "WebPage",
    "@id": "https://new.nat6.net/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/"
  },
  "url": "https://new.nat6.net/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/",
  "headline": "not getting into a philosophical debate, but this book really changed how I see the topic and made m...",
  "description": "不想陷入哲学辩论，但这本书确实改变了我对这个话题的看法，让我更加谦逊。人类智能令人印象深刻，但称其为\"通用\"并不太客观。我的猫会不同意。 在我看来，人类智能更应被视为社会驱动的认知适应，而且我们仍不理解、也远未用当前 AI 复现的智能领域还有巨大 WORLD。 [引用 @demishassabis]：Yann 在这里…",
  "articleSection": "其他",
  "keywords": "AI, X：谢赛宁 (@sainingxie)",
  "datePublished": "2025-12-22T19:57:29Z",
  "dateModified": "2026-11-05T20:56:41Z",
  "inLanguage": "zh-CN",
  "isAccessibleForFree": true,
  "author": {
    "@type": "Organization",
    "name": "橙子新闻编辑部",
    "url": "https://new.nat6.net/about/"
  },
  "publisher": {
    "@type": "NewsMediaOrganization",
    "@id": "https://new.nat6.net/#org",
    "name": "橙子新闻",
    "url": "https://new.nat6.net/",
    "logo": {
      "@type": "ImageObject",
      "url": "https://new.nat6.net/assets/img/logo-512.png",
      "width": 512,
      "height": 512
    }
  },
  "image": {
    "@type": "ImageObject",
    "url": "https://new.nat6.net/assets/img/og-default.png",
    "width": 1200,
    "height": 630
  },
  "isPartOf": {
    "@id": "https://new.nat6.net/#website"
  },
  "isBasedOn": "https://x.com/sainingxie/status/2003193193656135855",
  "citation": [
    "https://aihot.news/items/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5",
    "https://x.com/sainingxie/status/2003193193656135855"
  ],
  "license": "https://new.nat6.net/sources/",
  "about": [],
  "mentions": [
    {
      "@type": "Thing",
      "name": "X：谢赛宁 (@sainingxie)"
    }
  ],
  "speakable": {
    "@type": "SpeakableSpecification",
    "cssSelector": [
      "h1",
      ".article-summary"
    ]
  },
  "copyrightHolder": {
    "@type": "Organization",
    "@id": "https://new.nat6.net/#org",
    "name": "橙子新闻",
    "url": "https://new.nat6.net/"
  },
  "creditText": "橙子新闻（AI 摘要）；原文：X：谢赛宁 (@sainingxie)",
  "copyrightNotice": "© 2025 橙子新闻。标题与 AI 摘要基于 AIHOT 公开数据，原文版权归原媒体与作者所有；本站不镜像全文。",
  "copyrightYear": 2025,
  "alternativeHeadline": "not getting into a philosophical debate, but this book really changed how I see the topic and made m...",
  "abstract": "顶级科学家对AGI本质的深刻思辨，重新定义通用智能的边界与局限",
  "subjectOf": [
    {
      "@type": "DigitalDocument",
      "name": "not getting into a philosophical debate, but this book really changed how I see the topic and made m... (Markdown)",
      "url": "https://new.nat6.net/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/index.md",
      "encodingFormat": "text/markdown"
    },
    {
      "@type": "DigitalDocument",
      "name": "not getting into a philosophical debate, but this book really changed how I see the topic and made m... (JSON)",
      "url": "https://new.nat6.net/api/v1/articles/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5.json",
      "encodingFormat": "application/json"
    }
  ]
}
```

## 如何引用 / How to cite

- 引用格式 / Citation format (zh): 橙子新闻.《文章标题》. 发布日期. https://new.nat6.net/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/
- Citation format (en): Orange News. "Article title". Published YYYY-MM-DD. https://new.nat6.net/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/
- 回链要求 / Backlink: 引用请保留「橙子新闻」署名并回链 canonical URL；AI 摘要请注明数据来源 AIHOT；原文版权归原媒体与作者所有。
- Attribution & backlinks: Keep the "Orange News" attribution and link back to the canonical URL; cite AIHOT as the data source for AI summaries; original copyright remains with the original publishers and authors.

### 机器入口 / Machine entry points

- Markdown: https://new.nat6.net/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/index.md
- JSON: https://new.nat6.net/api/v1/articles/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5.json
- API 清单 / API index: https://new.nat6.net/api/v1/site.json
- Markdown 内容协商 / negotiation: 对 https://new.nat6.net/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/ 发送 `Accept: text/markdown`
