not getting into a philosophical debate, but this book really changed how I see the topic and made m...
Original title:not getting into a philosophical debate, but this book really changed how I see the topic and made m...
AI summary
Not looking to get into a philosophical debate, but this book really changed how I see this topic and made me more humble. Human intelligence is impressive, but calling it 'general' is not very objective. My cat would disagree. In my view, human intelligence is better seen as socially driven cognitive adaptation, and there remains a huge WORLD of intelligence that we still do not understand and are far from reproducing with current AI. [Quoting @demishassabis]: Yann is completely wrong here; he conflates general intelligence with universal intelligence. The brain is the most exquisite and complex phenomenon we know of in the universe (so far), and they are in fact extremely general. Obviously, no one can evade the no free lunch theorem, so in practical and finite systems there must always be some degree of specialization around the target distribution being learned. But the point about generality is that, in theory, in the Turing Machine sense, the architecture of such a general system can learn anything computable given enough time and memory (and data), and the human brain (and AI foundation models) are approximate Turing Machines. Finally, regarding Yann's comment on chess players, it is itself amazing that humans could invent chess (and all other aspects of modern civilization, from science to 747s!), let alone that someone like Magnus can play so well. He may not be strictly optimal (after all, he has finite memory and finite decision time), but considering that our brains evolved for hunting and gathering, it is incredible that he and all of us can do these things with our brains.
Key Takeaways
- Not looking to get into a philosophical debate,but this book really changed how I see this topic…
- Human intelligence is impressive,but calling it 'general' is not very objective.
- My cat would disagree.
- In my view,human intelligence is better seen as socially driven cognitive adaptation,and there…
- [Quoting @demishassabis]: Yann is completely wrong here
Quick Facts
- Published
- Updated
- Source
- X:谢赛宁 (@sainingxie)
- Category
- Other
顶级科学家对AGI本质的深刻思辨,重新定义通用智能的边界与局限
Source & copyright
This article is based on curated titles and AI summaries from the AIHOT public API, with attribution and links back. Original copyright remains with the original publishers and authors; this site does not mirror full texts.
How to Cite
When citing this article, keep the title, date, and permalink, and credit Orange News as the source.
Orange News: not getting into a philosophical debate, but this book really changed how I see the topic and made m.... December 23, 2025. https://new.nat6.net/en/news/cmnz6dpf302aksl0fh5j5was5/